Taiwan or Singapore: Who Has It Better?
Illustration · not a service recordThis Friday I am stepping into a match: Taiwan, Singapore and India have formed a “young people’s joint team,” and our opponent is the chief economist of DBS Bank. The motion: which generation has it better?
Last week the IMF projected that Taiwan’s economy will grow 10.7% this year, the highest in the Asia-Pacific. But ask young people in Taiwan, “Do you think you have it better than your parents’ generation?” and the answer is probably not as pretty.
At 4:30 p.m. on Friday, October 23, this debate in Singapore will be streamed live online. On one side are Gen Z and millennials; on the other, Gen X and baby boomers. Sitting across from us will be an investment firm CEO, a company founder, and the chief economist of DBS Bank. Debating a chief economist on the bank’s home turf does come with some pressure. What adds even more pressure is that the debate has to be in English...
But while preparing, another question kept popping into my head: Taiwan or Singapore, who has it better?
Taiwan and Singapore have no time difference, but there is plenty of “parallax” between them. Because we stand in different places, what each of us sees may actually be what is good about the other.
Looking at Singapore from Taiwan, what I admire most is that it treats “adult learning” as national infrastructure.
On the Monday after the debate, I have been invited to speak at a workshop of the Singapore Business Federation (SBF). The topic is using AI to turn what the strongest people in a company know how to do into abilities that everyone can learn. The venue is actually called the Lifelong Learning Institute. Behind it is the Singapore government’s Enterprise Workforce Transformation Package (EWTP), pushed jointly by several ministries with a budget of more than S$400 million, and SBF is the main point of contact for businesses.
When Taiwan talks about AI talent, this piece is surely being worked on, but it does not yet seem to be this comprehensive; Singapore already treats every company as a classroom.
Looking at Taiwan from Singapore, though, I think Taiwan has one thing that is hard to replicate: a spirit of experimentation on the front line.
Taiwan is big enough and diverse enough, from cities to mountains to outlying islands, that a method only counts if it works in very different classrooms. The civic sector, local governments and research institutions are willing to try things together and then let a third party test the results. Take the AI Notebook at Longpu Elementary School (龍埔國小) in New Taipei: after a full year of research, the children had become better at asking questions, and their scores when not using AI had not slipped either.
What has been honed in Taiwan’s classrooms can, in fact, travel. The poster for the SBF workshop says: AI should make people more capable, not more dependent. That is what we have been saying in Taiwan all along: turn AI’s strength into people’s strength. Junyi Academy’s ActiveAI has also completed its first full overseas corporate rollout in Singapore, to verify that the “Ask, Use, Manage, Build (問用管造)” methodology can cross not only national borders but also into the business world.
So, between Taiwan and Singapore, who has it better?
My tentative thought is this: having it good is not necessarily something you can compare directly, but it is something you can exchange.
Taiwan brings over the experience that has grown on the front line; Singapore lends us the design of its whole system as a reference. After the exchange, perhaps both sides will have it better.
As for which generation has it better? I will share that with everyone after Friday’s debate. (The livestream link is in the first comment. Taiwan and Singapore have no time difference, so let’s watch together at 4:30 p.m.)
- Original: Ray Lu’s personal Facebook post (published 2026-10-19)
Course titles follow the source. Check each course page for its teaching language.
AI Fluency: Framework and foundations
Practice delegation, description, discernment, and diligence with the 4D framework. Free course; completion badge after assessment.
Dissecting the Crawfish: How AI Agents Work, via OpenClaw
An OpenClaw-based introduction to how AI agents work. Free public lecture; no self-study certificate. Costs of independently using external models or tools are separate.